Moral conflict and collective intentionality an analysis from cooperation
Abstract
In this article, I argue that cooperation, which explains social reality, may not cease with Giannini’s offense and moral conflict. In the first section, I introduce to the problem, while in the second I briefly address the concepts of offense and moral conflict in Giannini’s philosophy. In the third section, I explore how collective intentionality is based upon cooperation and solemn pacts. Finally, I look at how the offense and moral conflict do not necessarily hinder high-level cooperation. Thus, I conclude that collective intentionality only stops when cooperation reaches an endpoint.Keywords:
Moral experience, Conflict, Collective intentionality, Cooperation, Solemn pactReferences
Bruna, Rosemary (2022), “La experiencia moral en clave afectiva: una lectura desde la obra de Humberto Giannini”. Hermenéutica Intercultural. 38: 29-50.
Chaplin, Charles (1931), “Boxing Match”, en City Lights. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9NfXIXzgnA.
Cook, Karen, Hardin, Russell y Margaret Levi (2005), Trust without Cooperation. Nueva York: Russell Sage Foundation.
De Waal, Frans (2005), Our Inner Ape. Nueva York: Penguin Books.
____ (2019), Mama’s Last Hug: Animal and Human Emotions. Nueva York: W.W. Norton.
Giannini, Humberto (1987), La reflexión cotidiana. Santiago: Editorial Universitaria.
____ (1992), La experiencia moral. Santiago: Editorial Universitaria.
____ (1997), Del bien que se espera y del bien que se debe. Santiago: Dolmen.
____ (2007), La metafísica eres tú. Santiago: Catalonia.
____ (2008), “Experiencia moral y acción comunicativa”. Revista de Filosofía. 64: 1-8.
____ (2015a), “Alimentar tortugas… ¿Para qué? Acerca de los límites de la comunicación”, en Giannini Público. Santiago: Vicerrectoría de Extensión y Comunicaciones y la Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades de la Universidad de Chile; pp. 257-262.
____ (2015b), “Sigo pensando en Sócrates, padre del diálogo callejero”, en Giannini Público. Santiago de Chile. Vicerrectoría de Extensión y Comunicaciones y la Facultad de Filosofía y Humanidades de la Universidad de Chile; pp. 179-189.
González, Rodrigo y Krause, María Soledad (2022), “Humanidad por defecto, cooperación por defecto”. Isegoría. 67, e19: 1-11.
López, María José y Giannini, Humberto (2014), “Comunicación, promesa y política: el poder de las promesas mutuas”. Revista Atenea. 509: 63-77.
Majeski, Stephen y Fricks, Shane (1995), “Conflict and cooperation in international relations”. The journal of conflict resolution. 39/4: 622-645.
Nowak, Martin y Highfield, Roger (2011), Supercooperators: Altruism, evolution, and why we need each other to succeed. Nueva York: Free Press.
Rakoczy, Hans y Tomasello, Michael (2007), “The Ontogeny of Social Ontology: Steps to Shred Intentionality and Status Functions”, en S. Tsohatzidis, ed., Intentional Acts and Institutional Facts. Dordrecht: Springer; pp. 113-137.
Rosati, Alexandra, DiNicola, Lauren y Buckholts, Joshua (2018), “Chimpanzee cooperation is fast and independent from self-control”. Psychological Science. 29/11: 1-14.
Schweikard, David y Schmid, Hans (2021), “Collective Intentionality”, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Edward N. Zalta, ed. <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2021/entries/collective-intentionality/>.
Searle, John (1969), Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Londres: Cambridge University Press.
____ (1989), “How performatives work.” Linguistics and Philosophy. 12/5: 535-558.
____ (1992), “Collective intentions and actions”, en P. Cohen, J. Morgan y M. Pollack, eds., Intentions in Communication. Cambridge Mass.: MIT Press; pp. 401-416.
____ (1997), La construcción de la realidad social. Barcelona: Paidós.
____ (2001), Rationality in Action. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
____ (2002), “Speech acts, mind and social reality”, en G. Grewendorf y G. Meddle, eds, Speech acts, mind and social reality. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers; pp. 3-16.
____ (2005), “What is an Institution?”. Journal of Institutional Economics. 1/1: 1-22.
____ (2010), Making the Social World: The Structure of Human Civilization. Oxford: Oxford UP.
Tomasello, Michael (2009), Why We Cooperate. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
____ (2019), Becoming Human: A Theory of Ontogeny. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard U P.
